Ad Spot

May 29, 2022

Appeals court to consider case of former Alabama man convicted in son’s hot-car death

A man whose toddler son died after he left him in a hot car for hours is asking Georgia’s highest court to overturn his convictions for murder and child cruelty.

Justin Ross Harris, 41, was convicted in November 2016 on eight counts including malice murder in the death of his 22-month-old son, Cooper. A judge sentenced him to life without parole as well as 32 more years in prison for other crimes.

Harris has appealed his convictions for murder and first-degree child cruelty. The Georgia Supreme Court scheduled oral arguments for Tuesday.

Harris, who moved from Tuscaloosa, Alabama, to the Atlanta area for work in 2012, told police he forgot to drop his son off at day care on the morning of June 18, 2014, driving straight to his job as a web developer for Home Depot without remembering that Cooper was still in his car seat.

Cooper died after sitting for about seven hours in the back seat of the vehicle outside his father’s office in suburban Atlanta, where temperatures that day reached at least into the high 80s.

Prosecutors argued at trial that Harris was unhappily married and killed his son on purpose to free himself. Defense attorneys described him as a doting father and said the boy’s death was a tragic accident.

Police officers who interacted with Harris after his son’s death didn’t think he acted the way a father should under the circumstances, and began investigating all aspects of his life, according to a defense brief filed with the high court.

Evidence showed he was a loving and attentive father, even if exchanging sexually explicit messages and graphic photos with women and teenage girls and meeting some of them for sex revealed that Harris was not a great husband, the defense brief says.

Investigators “cherry picked the mountain of electronic data to support the conclusion that (Harris) murdered his son, ignoring contrary evidence,” the brief says.

Harris’ lawyer, Mitch Durham, argues that the judge shouldn’t have admitted evidence of Harris’ extramarital communications and in-person trysts at trial because his sexual misconduct had nothing to do with the death of his child. Prosecutors argue that plenty of evidence was presented to allow jurors to infer that Harris “acted out of a desire to be free of his wife and son so that he could pursue his self-described sexual addiction.”

Durham argues that there was insufficient evidence to show that he intended to kill his son and that some of his internet searches, activity and messages were twisted to fit that narrative. He says the evidence of sexual misconduct served only to prejudice the jury against Harris.

The state, represented by the Cobb County district attorney’s office and the attorney general’s office, argues that the evidence of his sexual conduct outside his marriage is not irrelevant because it illustrates his motive for killing his son. To conclude that Harris did not act with malice or criminal negligence by leaving his son in a hot car, the high court “would have to ignore the evidence about Harris’ double life and its deep connection to his motive for killing Cooper.”

Durham also says the trial judge made mistakes in requiring the defense to disclose the notes of a defense expert, allowing the introduction of a 3D animated video and limiting the cross examination of certain witnesses. Each of those errors is enough to justify a new trial, but even if the high court finds each of them alone to be relatively harmless, their collective prejudicial effect is sufficient to authorize a new trial, Durham argues.

Prosecutors, on the other hand, say the trial judge correctly decided these issues and Harris’ convictions and sentence should be upheld.

“Cooper Harris did not get a second chance on June 18, 2014, and his father has fallen short of demonstrating that he is entitled to a second chance in this appeal,” the district attorney’s brief says.

News

Alabama man turned a Glock pistol into a illegal machine gun, feds say; he faces a decade in prison now

News

Alabama inmate who escaped with jailed will seek to move trials, attorney says

News

Alabama hospitals say COVID-19 patient counts on rise, again

News

Alabama man who bilked banks to buy Ferraris and Lamborghinis ordered to repay $12M serve 15 years in prison

News

Traffic stop on Alabama interstate leads to discovery of 129 pounds of marijuana in vehicle

News

Another Gulf Coast tragedy: 14-year-old boy missing in Alabama waters after father tried to save him

News

Alabama man kills wife, two teen girls, then turns gun on himself, police say

News

Man admits to bilking $1.3M from dozens of women posing as fake physician on dating sites

News

Police say roach infestation contributing cause of 72-year-old Alabama woman’s death. Two arrested on elderly abuse, neglect charges.

News

Alabama police: 5 of 6 juveniles involved in police chase arrested; 1 juvenile still at large. Chase started after report of drug activity at gas station.

News

Three church day care workers face dozens of abuse counts, some videoed, police say

News

‘Perversion of justice’ — Alabama DA says sentence inadequate for man who will spend less than 6 years behind bars for DUI wreck that left father, son with life changing injuries

News

Alabama inmate convicted of murdering 15-year-old in 2007 captured after escape

News

Child killed when car collides with tractor on Alabama highway

News

Alabama woman killed Sunday night in two-vehicle highway crash

News

Alabama man linked to 1988 killing of a sixth-grade girl in Massachusetts

News

Nick Saban: ‘We don’t tamper with anybody’ after Louisville coach accuses Alabama of mischief

News

Escaped fugitive, jailer had five guns and $29,000 in cash when captured; they were prepared for shootout, sheriff says

News

Police: Former Alabama jail official accused of helping inmate escape shot, killed herself

News

Alabama county corrections officer arrested, fired after he reportedly engaged in sex with inmate

News

Escaped Alabama inmate, jail official who disappeared more than a week ago captured in Indiana

News

The unsolved murder of Delange Harris — Alabama deputies working with ABI and FBI to solve 11 year-old murder case

News

Body of Alabama father who drowned during rescue of 6-year-old son recovered on Mother’s Day

News

Woman killed in weekend rural Alabama crash